[ILUG] E-voting in India
bryano at europlex.ie
Wed May 5 16:02:25 IST 2004
Timothy Murphy wrote:
> On Wednesday 05 May 2004 12:51, Bryan O'Donoghue wrote:
>>My position would be that, unless I as a citizen can verify that code, I
>>can't be satisfied that the system *isn't* compromised.
> Do you ever fly?
Flying is not a State service, nor the right of each competent minded citizen
of this Republic.
Aer Lingus is semi-State and flying on it, is not a civil right, if it were,
going to Spain on Aer Lingus would be free and every aspect of the service
would have to be accountable to the citizen.
Perhaps it is *already* I'm no expert on Aer Lingus.
I think the base case stands, ie, unless dissemination of information would be
harmful to the State and by extension it's citizens, information *cannot* be
kept private, if a citizen requests to see it.
I understand the point you're trying to make though.
Each time I get on an Airplane I choose to trust that the technicians have all
done their jobs properly, so why don't I trust that the E-Voting technicians
and the people in voting infrastructure are similarly above reproach?
The same question can be asked of the non E-Voting system.
Why don't we just *trust* that nothing untoward is happening in the normal
Why do we allow such a level of citizen scrutiny?
Explain to me, why it would be logically and morally acceptable to remove the
ability of the citizen to scrutanise the paper based electoral system and I'll
concede the point on E-Voting source code.
It's the same argument.
Embedded Software Engineer
Europlex Technologies Ltd
Clonshaugh Business & Technology Park
T:+353 (0) 1 2500500
F:+353 (0) 1 2500590
E:bryano at euoplex.ie
More information about the ILUG